Wednesday, 30 November 2011
Week 10 - American Consumerisum
Sunday, 27 November 2011
The American dream
Friday, 25 November 2011
Week 9: The Horatio Alger Myth in Contemporary America
Horatio Alger. Jr's Ragged Dick centres around the notion of the 'American Dream' through the concept of rags to riches. These ideas, as well as others, are essentially what the Horatio Alger Myth is based upon. This article by Sara Bilodeau shows how the notion still exists within society today, and how it can be applied to contemporary America.
One important aspect to the Horatio Alger Myth is how hard work leads to success. In Ragged Dick this concept is clearly visible, 'A good many distinguished men have once been poor boys. There's hope for you, Dick, if you'll try." (p.27) Bilodeau has applied this idea to contempoary America, "It is true that some Americans are able to achieve this myth within their lifetime, such as Bill Gates, but it is much more common for this goal to be obtained after several generations of hard work." Bilodeau portrays the idea of hard work for some as much easier than for others. Nonetheless, she recognises the importance that it has within the United States, and essentially the 'American Dream' as well as staying truthful to the Horatio Alger and the Horatio Alger Myth.
In addition to this, the idea of education is also another important aspect to the Horatio Alger Myth. According to Bilodeau education to date has a slightly different function to that which can be seen in Ragged Dick. For example, Alger's message within the book was that, as well as looking respectable, the only way of gaining a suitable standard within society to have a 'proper' education, "But, in order to succeed well, you must manage to get as good an education as you can. Until you do, you cannot get a position in an office, or counting room even to run errands." (p.36) In contrast however, Bilodeau portrays how nowadays there are financial benefits for those of the lower classes, "... the children of lower-class families have numerous opportunities to receive financial assistance to go to college if not a full ride to one... in order to go to college all you basically have to do is finish high school with relatively good grades." This shows how the importance of education to obtaining a good job has changed and developed over time. Now, thanks to 'financial asscistance' more people from the lower class are able to achieve good work than before.
Overall, through the concept of hard work and the importance of education, Bolideau has shown how the Horatio Alger Myth still exists within America today. Despite the fact that it has changed and differed slightly, like all things over time, the importance of hard work and education are still important factors to helping people reach their ideal 'American Dream'. In the words of Bilodeau herslef, "Although it may seem that the Horatio Alger Myth is unattainable, that is not the case. The hard work that is required to fulfill the myth is slightly different from the hard work that was originally implied, however, the myth still holds true and success is obtainable to even the most humble of people. All that is needed is the drive to succeed and an education."
Thursday, 24 November 2011
Week 9 - The Horatio Alger Myth
Wednesday, 23 November 2011
Contemporary 'Horation Alger myth' Use
The Horatio Alger myth is the idea of “rags to riches”, “American Dream” and that from poor beginnings one can rise to have success.
I found an article on Joseph Michael Jaber who grew up as one of nine children to Lebanese immigrants and for a long time was “very, very poor”; but then became a Superior Judge. The title of the article caught my attention: From modest beginnings, great success. This alone is an example of the Horatio Alger myth which implies that you can rise from poor beginnings to become very successful. Jaber’s life follows this and despite some difference is actually quite accurate in relation to Ragged Dick. Jaber, like Ragged Dick, studied hard and got an education, and went on to have a position in society; and according to the article, Jaber was in “pursuit of his share of the American Dream”.
However, the article also points to an inaccuracy in relation to Ragged Dick. For example Jaber grew up “very, very poor, much as everyone down here was”. This last bit exemplifies how the Horatio Alger myth is not relevant to everyone, as from as far as this article implies, one else from his childhood community grew up to be successful like him, although it could be implied that they did not work hard; like Johnny Nolan in Ragged Dick who said that he could not learn how to read, almost refusing to. As I found in another example (Why Does the Myth of Horatio Alger Linger?), it seems almost impractical to suggest that the Horatio Alger myth can be realised by any and everyone. This is also something that Alger appears to imply in Ragged Dick, because if the other boot-blacks were like Ragged Dick who is ambitious and aims higher than himself, then they too would also become successful.
http://open.salon.com/blog/paul_nevins/2011/02/12/why_does_the_myth_of_horatio_alger_linger
Sunday, 20 November 2011
Saturday, 19 November 2011
Week 8: Pro & Anti Gun Control Websites
http://www.keepandbeararms.com/
'Keep and Bear Arms' is an anti gun control website, set up by people of the United States. Their main aim is to help '...lawful people maintain their abilities to protect themselves and the people they love effectively from anyone who would do them harm - through legal, private ownership and use of guns.' From this it is clear that the main belief that this anti gun website holds is that guns are a way of protecting family and friends through self defence. Furthermore, the Keep and Bear Arms website offers people the chance to become a member, which allows regular members to post on chat rooms. This enables them to have free speech on the issue of gun control, which in turn supports the website as a whole. The Keep and Bear Arms movement makes many references to the amendment of the Bill of rights, and in particular the notion of freedom, which is the obvious foundation on which they rest their views. In addition to this, the organisation have many interesting beliefs, one being that the media is biased against firearms and it is up to them to take 'appropriate action'. Whilst exploring the website, I also found the the word 'educate' came up a lot. For example, '...educate you about current problems facing our liberties and exactly what you CAN do about it.' However, the use of 'educate' could merely be a way for the website to feed people information about their views, rather than actually 'educating' people about what is really happening in the USA, on the issue of gun control. I also found the wording on the website quite patronising, in a way that subtly passes their views onto the reader, regardless of what their view on gun ownership maybe. 'If you've been sitting on the sidelines passively watching our Second Amendment being eroded away, it's okay. You're here now...' It is true to say that their loyalty towards 'freedom' and the right to own guns undoubtedly goes unnoticed.
PRO GUN CONTROL
http://www.asahi-net.or.jp/~zj5j-gttl/guns.htm
This website titled 'A Case for Gun Control' is a clear representative for pro gun control. In comparison to the previous website, it makes a lot of references to the second amendment of the Bill of Rights. However, what I found interesting on this website was that it held views that some of the amendments were not 'absolute', for example '...even though the 1st Amendment guarantees me the right to free speech, the right is limited.' I found this very surprising for obvious reasons, such as the fact that the Bill of Rights is held in such high esteem for the American people, and yet these individuals are willing to criticise it. However, this is indeed a valid point which many Americans would agree with. The website also draws heavily on the view that guns are used for self-defense, and offers sufficient evidence to show how this is not always the case, 'Dr. Roth argues that "Self-defense is commonly cited as a reason to own a gun. This is the explanation given by 20 percent of all gun owners...But research has shown that a gun kept in the home is 43 times more likely to kill a member of the household, or friend, than an intruder.' By offering this as a piece of evidence, I believe that it strengthens this argument as it has been applied to actual society rather than the beliefs of a few.
Overall, I consider the pro gun control website to be more convincing for many reasons, but primarily because it hold views and beliefs to that of my own. In addition to this, I found that the way the 'Keep and Bear Arms' website spoke to the audience was too abrupt, as if it were trying to impose its views which I found off putting. However, a significant point to make is that the importance of America's freedom cannot go unrecognised. The fact that 'Keep and Bear Arms' stands up for what it believes in is a significant factor within the arguments for pro and anti gun control.
Thursday, 17 November 2011
Week 8 - Gun Control
Pro-gun Control and Anti-gun Control
GOAL (Gun Owners’ Action League) is an anti-gun control website and their core belief is; “the basic right of firearms ownership for competition, recreation and self-protection.” They also claim to “hard to defend the Constitution and the Bill of Rights against those in Massachusetts who wish to infringe upon the freedoms guaranteed by our forefathers”. This was not very surprising as I expected this from a pro-gun control organization. However, what I did not expect was their “education” in which they teach young children and youths that guns are not toys or a means to resolve an argument. This definitely changed my opinion that introducing young people to guns would encourage them to misuse them. The League also helps to educate all people on gun use and have a section which states all the laws for owning a gun. I found this to be very helpful and it also kept in theme with their want to educate all people. What I also found very interesting was that this site was for pro-gun control in Massachusetts which also highlights how different states operate and what the feeling of gun control is in a particular state. On the other hand, as expected, there was a lot of text about maintaining the rights and freedom of America as well as links to make donations and a store, which would presumably raise funds for the organization.
BradyCampaign.org is an organisation that works to prevent gun violence. Their mission is to create “an America free from gun violence, where all Americans are safe at home, at school, at work, and in our communities.” Their website has a lot of information about gun violence ordered in specific sections. The information is displayed clearly and is easy for anyone to read and understand. They also have other sections which lead onto further information such as: a blog, press releases, news and learn more. Also in the top right hand corner is a counter that shows how many people have been shot today, based on the estimates of how many people are shot on average. This really makes the effects of gun violence real and makes it more personal.
Similar to the GOAL website, bradycampaign.org also asks for donations which also shows that they need funds to help their organisation and that both sides (anti and pro gun control movements) need support from the public in order to continue putting forward their views.
Out of the two, I find the GOAL website to be more convincing because although they endorse gun ownership, they want to educate children and everyone about the uses and dangers of guns and they also provide all the information on gun laws.
Sunday, 13 November 2011
manifest destin
American Wilderness
Friday, 11 November 2011
Week 7: Manifest Destiny
http://www.treefrogtreasures.com/reference/ttmmrblinesBC43083.html
Nineteenth Century Painting: Thomas Cole, The Oxbow
This painting was made in 1836 and it is of Mount Holyoke, Northampton, Massachusetts. It was originally called: View from Mount Holyoke, Northampton, Massachusetts, after a Thunderstorm—The Oxbow. This painting depicts the vastness of the American landscape and of its natural beauty.
The right half of the painting shows the land has been cultivated and settled, with patches of fields and trees that have been planted. It also shows mountains in the distance which symbolise the various heights of America and shows a difference to Europe as there were not many mountains. This cultivated side of the landscape shows that America is an open land and that there are opportunities for growth, as crops and trees are growing. It almost romanticises America, which is also interesting as Cole was the founder of the Hudson River School art movement, which painted romanticised pictures of the American landscape. The pale blue sky shows that things are peaceful and again makes America appear to be very romantic. The distant mountains and hills in the background also show that America is the land of opportunity as it goes on for miles and miles. The river almost symbolises and predestines the journey that America has been on and the journey ahead, as well as the twists and turns that are represented by the oxbow. This is also an example of the idea of manifest destiny, where it was thought it was predestined that America would be great. However, as the river is calm and gently it falsely portrays this journey as it does not indicate the civil war or the massacres of the native peoples or the hardships of the great depression.
The left half on the painting shows a different side of America. The land is uncultivated, the trees look unruly and the sky is dark and it looks like a thunderstorm is about to start. This shows the ugly side of America and that everything is not what it seems despite the beauty of the right-hand side of the painting. Contrary to the right side, the left-hand side of the painting looks savage, a term that was used heavily to describe the native peoples. This shows what America was like before the settlers arrived and transformed the landscape, and also represents the native peoples before the Europeans arrived and drove them out. The left side also represents uncertainty, but with a glimmer of hope as there appears to be light coming in through the dark clouds. There is a circle of birds in this light which is reminiscent of the story of Noah and the Ark; this links to something that Thomas Paine said in 1776: “We have it in our power to begin the world over again. A situation, similar to the present, has not happened since the days of Noah until now. The birthday of a new world is at hand”.
The two opposing sides of the painting look to show a “before and after” view, as well as a well-rounded view of America.
Thursday, 10 November 2011
Sunday, 6 November 2011
Saturday, 5 November 2011
week 6 - tea party movement
The tea party movement is a political movement generally recognised as conservative and libertarian and associate themselves as republicans. The modern day tea parties were established not long after the election of Barack Obama to the White House. The tea parties are in reference to the Boston tea party - a protest by colonists who objected to a British tax on tea in 1773 and demonstrated by dumping British tea into the harbour. The tea party has no central leadership but it is composed of a loose affiliation of national local groups that determine their own platforms and agendas.
The tea party patriots (http://teapartypatriots.ning.com/) is the official home of the American tea party movement, the tea party patriots slogan is ‘’A community committed to standing together, shoulder to shoulder, to protect our country and the Constitution upon which we were founded!’’
This website makes use of various forms of media such as photos, videos, blog posts, and forums to attract the attention of the public and influence membership for the movement. However you are required to register to become a member in order to access this material. This may have been done to ensure that opposition are unable to comment and turn members against the movement and dissuade people from joining. However this may also backfire as people are less likely to bother joining in order to search the website, people are more likely to join if they are able to access the site freely and browse the material without registering and then make a decision to join.
Once I joined the site and became a member I was able to get full access to the material available on the site, I browsed through the photos and found many people had uploaded photos of themselves and others at protests and campaigns and also many had uploaded propaganda images persuading people to join the tea party movement, however these photos are only available to existing members and are more aimed at those who have not yet joined and are thinking about joining. Therefore this purpose has been defeated. There are also many blogs and forums which discuss the main points that surround the tea party movement, discussions particularly on taxes, government spending, anti – Obama related topics and immigration related topics.
Friday, 4 November 2011
The Tea Party
Teaparty.org is a prime example of the Tea Party, in the way that it holds very Republican views on issues such as immigration, taxes, jobs and Obamacare.
The website features many icons that you can click on in order to join the Party. It also has many icons that link to sending donations to the army. The power of military and military presence is one of the historic values of the Republicans and this shows that the Tea Party strongly advocate the values that first started to the Republican Party. Another example which highlights some of the Tea Party’s ideals is; “Due to the devastating effects of mass illegal immigration” (taken from http://www.teaparty.org/article.php?id=1600, 7 Billion and Still Counting). This shows that immigration is a big problem as the population around the world, as well as in America, is growing rapidly. In this article it claims that “those illegally entering will produce more children who will be undereducated and not inculcated in American culture.” As the Republican Party are conservative, they would be interested in making sure that all American citizens are immersed in American culture, so it would make lots of sense that the Tea Party would also be very concerned for the levels of immigration, but especially illegal immigration, something that Governor Brewer claims that Obama needs illegal immigrants in order to gain votes as seen in http://www.teaparty.org/article.php?id=1604.
However, the credibility of the website should be taken into account. Although it features many news articles and has links to donations and joining the party, the website is not an official Tea Party website. From having looked at many different Tea Party websites, this is merely one of many that have been set up. Looking at the layout and presentation of the website, it looks as though it was set up by a member of the Tea Party and gained followers through Facebook and Twitter (it also has links to these websites as well). Also, as it is hard to determine how many Tea Parties there are, it also raises the question of how valid this website is, as it could have been written by anyone.
Having researched a few Tea Party websites and party groups, it is fair to say that the Tea Party do hold on to the conservative and historic values of the republic as well as the Republican Party. Although some of their views may be a bit extreme and nonsensical (as seen in the youtube video shown in Wednesday's workshop), a lot of their views are indeed valid but are mostly based on some of the Republican views.
Week 6 - The New Republic: "Tea Party"
Week 6 - Tea Party Websites
Wednesday, 2 November 2011
In letter 111 of letters of an American farmer, de Crevecoeur focuses on the definition of American and what it means to be an American.
‘’here individuals of all nations are melted into a new race of men’’, in this statement de Crevecoeur recognises that America is initially built up of many different nations conquering and migrating to the new America and therefore they are not all one single nationality but a mixture and therefore look to nationalism and patriotism to unite them as one country. They are putting their old nationalities aside and become American despite what origin is in their blood.
‘’Being an American is more than a matter of where you or your parents came from. It is a belief that all men are created free and equal.’’ This is a quote by Harry Truman on October 26th 1948, in this statement we see that centuries on this opinion of Americans are still aware that they do not originate from the same place however they are ‘created free and equal’’; it is the idea that being American allows you to achieve anything and be whoever you want to be.